Round 3 review

Deep audits: Padrón · Perdomo · Crowned Heads · Rocky Patel · LFD · Room 101 · Oliva · Plasencia · Arturo Fuente leftovers · full plan & status

✓ Your reportRoom 101 17th Anniversary was missing

Root cause: the LLM classifier folded 17th Anniversary listings into the 10th and 15th Anniversary cards, so the 17th never got its own card.

Fixed: 17th Anniversary now has its own card (5+ offers), one card per anniversary year (10th/12th/13th/14th/15th/17th), and a golden regression test asserts the 15th/17th split can't regress. Full brand sweep included: Big Payback, Doomsayer (Aggressive=Maduro / Passive=Habano, verified on tinderbox), and Johnny Tobacconaut satellite brands all fold into Room 101 now.

R8Atlantic "Oliva Small Batch Double Robusto Maduro Box Pressed 10-Pack" ($9.34/stick)

Question: which blend is this? Atlantic's own metadata calls it "Oliva Serie V Maduro", but the name says "Small Batch" — could be an unbanded Serie V Maduro small-batch run, or a distinct factory blend. No other shop carries it.

✅ Applied (safe default): kept under Oliva as its own "Small Batch Double Robusto" card, low confidence — not folded into Serie V Maduro. Say "fold the Oliva Small Batch Double into Serie V Maduro" to merge it, or "ignore-tag R8" to drop it to the shop card.

👀 View at Atlantic

What round 3 changed — this session (Room 101, R7, Oliva, Plasencia, Fuente)
  • Room 101 — 17th Anniversary un-fold (above); Big Payback / Doomsayer / Johnny Tobacconaut satellite brands folded in; Doomsayer split Aggressive/Passive; Nickel City + Big Payback Hueso kept as distinct editions; JT card consolidated 13 → 7 sizes; anniversary case fixes ("12Th" → "12th").
  • R7 rounding snap (deferred from round 2) — shops round fractional dims differently (5 1/8 → 5.1 vs 5.13), splitting one vitola into near-identical rows. A guarded generic snap folded 120 duplicate size rows; 90 lookalike pairs correctly kept apart (different vitola/leaf, or one shop stocks both = two real products; pinned rows immune).
  • Oliva — Cain restored as its own brand family (base / F / Daytona); Cain-Nub crossovers land on Nub (Cain / Cain F); Nub Nuance consolidated to Roast / Double Roast / Triple Roast with cigarillos as vitolas; Serie V Melanio limited editions get one card per year (EL 2018–2025); seven Flor de Oliva naming variants folded to three cards (base / Gold / Giants); Talavera Edición Exclusiva rebuilt (Toro Pressed / Round / Gordo); swapped Oliva↔Plasencia cutters fixed both directions; two-box cross-brand bundles → samplers.
  • Plasencia — ~70 → ~40 honest cards. Vitola-named fragments (Eduardo I, Robustus I/II/Corto, Generación V, Nestor IV, Sixto I/II, Amanecer/Boreal/Celeste, Cosecha La Musica/La Vega/Monte Carlo/San Agustín/San Luis/Azacualpa/Cortez/Santa Fe/La Tradición/San Diego, 1898 Salomones) folded into their parent cards. "El Año del Caballo" unified with Year of the Horse; Explorer/Robusto Collection variants → Colección Explorador/Robusto; Cachitos merged; strays returned home (Kristoff Signature Series 2025 PCA, Rojas Street Tacos Cinco de Mayo 2026, LCT Four Wrappers sampler).
  • Arturo Fuente leftovers — Eye of the Bull (9 offers) and Eye of the Shark (6 offers) consolidated as Don Carlos vitolas across seven shops; OpusX tins-of-3 fold in-line as size rows on Angel's Share / Oro Oscuro / base OpusX (same rule as 5-packs), Rare Estate Reserve tins keep their own edition card; Destino al Siglo brand split healed; retailer mega-bundles + holiday collections flagged samplers so they leave the cigar view; cryptic "A Fuente Chat F King B Ros S/G" decoded → Chateau Fuente King B.
What round 3 changed — earlier checkpoint (Padrón, Perdomo, Crowned Heads, Rocky Patel, LFD)

Committed as the round-3 checkpoint before this session (≈6,600 override rows + grouping fixes):

  • Perdomo (204 rows) — 52-size base blob dispersed into real lines; Epicure fragments folded.
  • Padrón (145 rows) — 1964 Anniversary fragments folded; 80-size "Series" blob dispersed; Black No. 97 dupe resolved.
  • Crowned Heads (119 rows) — line fragments and edition variants consolidated.
  • Rocky Patel (62 rows) — Edge/The Edge unified; Thirtieth/30th spelling folds; Hamlet, 1865 Project; Statesman lighters → accessories.
  • La Flor Dominicana (24 rows) — Salomon Unico dupe folded; 30 Years vs 30th Anniversary split kept honest; humidor sets → accessories/samplers.
  • Tatuaje (44 rows) — residual round-2 strays picked up by the same sweep.

Catalog v370 · 7,998 line cards · golden tests 34/34 · question file: notes/round3-questions.json